Is radar too good, or 1st person view too useless?
-
- Private First Class
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Fri Jan 06, 2006 11:17 pm
- Location: NYC
Is radar too good, or 1st person view too useless?
Admit it: even though there's a lovely 3D view out your front window, you look at radar most of the time.
Admit it: when you get a blindness flag, you go on playing normally. when you get a jamming flag, you're in constant worry and can't wait for it to be over.
Sometimes I wonder if the 3D aspects of the game even matter, except in a few instances. I often feel like I'm playing a 2D game in the lower left hand corner of my screen, and just getting a little extra info from the rest of the real estate.
These are just a few things that indicate Radar might be out of balance in BZFlag.
Thoughts?
Admit it: when you get a blindness flag, you go on playing normally. when you get a jamming flag, you're in constant worry and can't wait for it to be over.
Sometimes I wonder if the 3D aspects of the game even matter, except in a few instances. I often feel like I'm playing a 2D game in the lower left hand corner of my screen, and just getting a little extra info from the rest of the real estate.
These are just a few things that indicate Radar might be out of balance in BZFlag.
Thoughts?
- Davy Jones
- Private First Class
- Posts: 297
- Joined: Thu Jan 04, 2007 4:39 am
- Location: Davy Jone's Locker
- A Meteorite
- Private First Class
- Posts: 1786
- Joined: Thu Apr 28, 2005 12:56 am
- Location: California, U.S.
- Contact:
I'm pretty sure most of the good players are actually going to disagree with you and agree with rolling_blunder.Davy Jones wrote:I'm pretty sure most of us are going to disagree with you
I'm with rolling_blunder as well. I barely use the window except in close dogfights. Other than that it's all radar. And I do perfectly fine (dare I say, way above average?).
And about confusing pyramids and boxes: that's why you play the map long enough to know what they are. And if you still can't tell where you are based on your radar alone then the map has a serious playability problem.
Owner @ BZFX
Core Admin @ CAN
Email me: bzmet…@gmail.com
rolling_blunder, you hit the nail on the head. I *do* panic when I have jamming but play normally even with blindness. The only times when radar is not good and in fact might hurt me is when I am trying to make a long range laser shot, dogfights (as meteorite said), or...well thats about it.
However, I disagree that it is out of balance. The radar is part of the game and isn't unfair or unbalanced by any means. Some people might find the window view better than radar, and if so, they have that choice. Choosing radar to help me out primarily is a strategy, not an advantage or cheat (if that's what you meant or hinted at)
However, I disagree that it is out of balance. The radar is part of the game and isn't unfair or unbalanced by any means. Some people might find the window view better than radar, and if so, they have that choice. Choosing radar to help me out primarily is a strategy, not an advantage or cheat (if that's what you meant or hinted at)
- The Red Baron
- Sergeant First Class
- Posts: 987
- Joined: Sat Dec 07, 2002 6:21 am
- Contact:
two very major leagues disaggree with you. Http://my.bzflag.org/league Http://www.gu.bzleague.comDavy Jones wrote:I'm pretty sure most of us are going to disagree with you
But it is what makes bzflag good.
Most of us can't use radar to rico off pyramids, as †hey show up as boxes in the current mode
There are many other factors against and for your argument.
But i think most of us like the radar how it is
and I personally disagree with you.
I find the HUD useless, radar is everything. Don't mess with my radar
Beware! I'm going to clone myself and spread those clones all over the world!
- Davy Jones
- Private First Class
- Posts: 297
- Joined: Thu Jan 04, 2007 4:39 am
- Location: Davy Jone's Locker
- A Meteorite
- Private First Class
- Posts: 1786
- Joined: Thu Apr 28, 2005 12:56 am
- Location: California, U.S.
- Contact:
Modifying the radar wasn't even mentioned.Davy Jones wrote:That's not what i mean...I meant that mod...ing the radar would not be very good for the game, as most like it how it is.
Owner @ BZFX
Core Admin @ CAN
Email me: bzmet…@gmail.com
- A Vicious Muffin
- Private First Class
- Posts: 534
- Joined: Sat Aug 26, 2006 12:25 am
- Location: Drury Lane
Yes, the radar is everything, dodging, knowing where people are, where to rico off things, and how to get places. It's everything.
However, look at it this way. It is important, but imagine if BZFlag didn't have a HUD. It was just one big giant radar with dots moving on it. A lot less fun, and to me, it seems more confusing. Yes, radar is a crucial part of the game, but you also should also look out your HUD. Take a look at any one of louman's maps. It's a work of art, a masterpiece. How would it look on a radar?
My two cents.
However, look at it this way. It is important, but imagine if BZFlag didn't have a HUD. It was just one big giant radar with dots moving on it. A lot less fun, and to me, it seems more confusing. Yes, radar is a crucial part of the game, but you also should also look out your HUD. Take a look at any one of louman's maps. It's a work of art, a masterpiece. How would it look on a radar?
My two cents.
The radar is actually part of the HUD, along with any other onscreen text and visual. HUD stands for Heads Up Display. The 3D view is not the HUD.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heads-up_display
Anyway, Jeff has called the game 2.5D because of the high reliance on a 2D representation of the world. Some have suggested making the radar more of a rough representation. (Maybe more like a circular rotating radar representation) I am unsure how this would affect BZFlag as we know it.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heads-up_display
Anyway, Jeff has called the game 2.5D because of the high reliance on a 2D representation of the world. Some have suggested making the radar more of a rough representation. (Maybe more like a circular rotating radar representation) I am unsure how this would affect BZFlag as we know it.
- The Red Baron
- Sergeant First Class
- Posts: 987
- Joined: Sat Dec 07, 2002 6:21 am
- Contact:
from my understanding, Jeff would like to make a circular radar, with a representation of the map, and something akin to halo's motion sensor. or so I last talke to him.blast wrote:The radar is actually part of the HUD, along with any other onscreen text and visual. HUD stands for Heads Up Display. The 3D view is not the HUD.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heads-up_display
Anyway, Jeff has called the game 2.5D because of the high reliance on a 2D representation of the world. Some have suggested making the radar more of a rough representation. (Maybe more like a circular rotating radar representation) I am unsure how this would affect BZFlag as we know it.
The Huge reliace on the radar/2D representation of the world, was introduced with the config, and the ability to modify the radar sizing. That was when player discovered you could post bigger sizes then what the GUI options specified.
Technically, you could say that the radar has been "abused" and "exploited." But in my understanding of the history of bz... thats where alot of the Flags have their origin.
Beware! I'm going to clone myself and spread those clones all over the world!
- Davy Jones
- Private First Class
- Posts: 297
- Joined: Thu Jan 04, 2007 4:39 am
- Location: Davy Jone's Locker
I'm sorry if i led you to the wrong conclusion about my thoughts-I was saying i disagree with that the 3D aspects don't matter, as AVM said, quite frankly, having it just have a big radar would make me quit.Sometimes I wonder if the 3D aspects of the game even matter, except in a few instances. I often feel like I'm playing a 2D game in the lower left hand corner of my screen, and just getting a little extra info from the rest of the real estate.
These are just a few things that indicate Radar might be out of balance in BZFlag.
I LIKE the view out the radar, and i usually turn the opacity so i can see through the radar, i personally only have it 3 or 4 above default, which is pretty small, but i can live with it.
-
- Private First Class
- Posts: 8
- Joined: Fri Jan 06, 2006 11:17 pm
- Location: NYC
thanks for your comments everyone, i'm not too surprised that so many agree, but i wanted to see for sure.
anyway, i'm not advocating for getting rid of the radar, or unilaterally nerfing it for everyone. i think that a forced decision like that would be against the spirit of this kind of open-source game. servers should be able to run as they like, and many of the maps now are very dependent on radar the way it is.
but i do think that, at present, the 3D aspect is underutilized. players are going to use whatever works to win, and right now the radar is "stronger", so the 3D side sort of atrophies. yes, there are many beautifully designed levels, but honestly i rarely notice.
i think radar is pretty crucial in BZF, especially in free-for-alls where enemies can spawn all over the place. but some nerfing might actually open up whole new aspects of gameplay. it would be great if you used radar to see that someone was behind you, but then you'd have to use the window view to really fight them accurately. or to have a CTF game where radar was so nerfed that you had to use teamwork to keep any opponents from getting behind your front lines, where they could pick your whole team off.
so let's hear some ideas for things that could be built into new maps or future versions of BZF to re-balance things! Here's a few:
Idea #1: allow the server to limit the radar views that are available. for instance, only allowing 1, 2, or 3 fixed sizes, unchangeable. i could imagine a well-made map that only allowed one very "zoomed out" radar view as being really fun.
Idea #2: create some new radar variables that can be chosen by the server, such as:
- a degree of fuzziness
- motion-sensor only
- only show tanks within a certain range
- only show team flags & carriers
Got more??
anyway, i'm not advocating for getting rid of the radar, or unilaterally nerfing it for everyone. i think that a forced decision like that would be against the spirit of this kind of open-source game. servers should be able to run as they like, and many of the maps now are very dependent on radar the way it is.
but i do think that, at present, the 3D aspect is underutilized. players are going to use whatever works to win, and right now the radar is "stronger", so the 3D side sort of atrophies. yes, there are many beautifully designed levels, but honestly i rarely notice.
i think radar is pretty crucial in BZF, especially in free-for-alls where enemies can spawn all over the place. but some nerfing might actually open up whole new aspects of gameplay. it would be great if you used radar to see that someone was behind you, but then you'd have to use the window view to really fight them accurately. or to have a CTF game where radar was so nerfed that you had to use teamwork to keep any opponents from getting behind your front lines, where they could pick your whole team off.
so let's hear some ideas for things that could be built into new maps or future versions of BZF to re-balance things! Here's a few:
Idea #1: allow the server to limit the radar views that are available. for instance, only allowing 1, 2, or 3 fixed sizes, unchangeable. i could imagine a well-made map that only allowed one very "zoomed out" radar view as being really fun.
Idea #2: create some new radar variables that can be chosen by the server, such as:
- a degree of fuzziness
- motion-sensor only
- only show tanks within a certain range
- only show team flags & carriers
Got more??
- The Red Baron
- Sergeant First Class
- Posts: 987
- Joined: Sat Dec 07, 2002 6:21 am
- Contact:
if you mean ricocheting off a pyramid, to hit a wing dude, or some one in the air, without using hud is impossible...WarPig wrote:although i admit to watching the radar most of the time, i disagree that radar should be changed, the radar is what makes it fun. also, as many have said. re-bounding shots of pryramids is simply impossible without a 3D view!
You're wrong. its quite possible. i do it all the time, and I'm not the only one. its rather easily done.
Beware! I'm going to clone myself and spread those clones all over the world!
Actually i agree a little both ways...more toward Davy Jones
i love useing the first person window...it is what makes bzlflag, BZFLAG
i use both about equally...the radar and window...
if we didn't have the 3d part of it this game would have never become this popular or exciting ...bzflag would flat out suck
just my thoughts...
-Rover
i love useing the first person window...it is what makes bzlflag, BZFLAG
i use both about equally...the radar and window...
if we didn't have the 3d part of it this game would have never become this popular or exciting ...bzflag would flat out suck
just my thoughts...
-Rover
COP@:
BOXY
VIPER
HEPCAT
BOXY
VIPER
HEPCAT
- The Red Baron
- Sergeant First Class
- Posts: 987
- Joined: Sat Dec 07, 2002 6:21 am
- Contact:
I believe its the reverse. Bzflag without the radar would flat out suck. And the radar is what makes bzflag, bzflag.Rover Blaster wrote:Actually i agree a little both ways...more toward Davy Jones
i love useing the first person window...it is what makes bzlflag, BZFLAG
i use both about equally...the radar and window...
if we didn't have the 3d part of it this game would have never become this popular or exciting ...bzflag would flat out suck
just my thoughts...
-Rover
What other games have a radar equivalent to bzflag?
Beware! I'm going to clone myself and spread those clones all over the world!
I never said anything about getting rid of radar...i was just talking about the 3D aspect of the gameThe Red Baron wrote: I believe its the reverse. Bzflag without the radar would flat out suck. And the radar is what makes bzflag, bzflag.
What other games have a radar equivalent to bzflag?
COP@:
BOXY
VIPER
HEPCAT
BOXY
VIPER
HEPCAT
And neither did he..off the top of my head, I can't think of any similar games with a radar near the quality of the BZ-radar.Rover Blaster wrote:I never said anything about getting rid of radar...i was just talking about the 3D aspect of the gameThe Red Baron wrote: I believe its the reverse. Bzflag without the radar would flat out suck. And the radar is what makes bzflag, bzflag.
What other games have a radar equivalent to bzflag?